DeLong Smackdown Watch: The Tradition of all Dead Generations Weighs Like a Nightmare on the Brains of the Living
Paul Krugman on the Difference Between Planetary Physics on the One Hand and Economics on the Other

Left Neoliberalism Versus... What, Exactly? It Is Not at All Clear...

Noah Millman:

Alternatives to Neoliberalism | Politics | The American Scene: Neither of [Matthew Yglesias's] critics are primarily saying that neoliberal policy ideas are bad. [Doug Henwood and Henry Farrell] are saying that neoliberalism is bad politics – not because it can’t win an election, but because it is based on running on good ideas, winning elections, and then implementing those good ideas. And that’s not a self-sustaining politics. From a more traditional left-wing perspective, you don’t start with good ideas – you start with ideas for how to establish enduring power bases.

Broadly speaking, the alternatives to liberalism reject the goal of finding the best policy, meaning the policy that will benefit the most people, in favor of promoting policies that may hurt more people than they help, but that shift the balance of power in favor of the group you’re seeking to represent....

The broad point is: alternatives to neoliberalism won’t be as liberal. They be less-likely to prioritize efficiency. They will also be less-likely to prioritize positive-sum solutions. They will also be less-likely to prioritize basic fairness or democratic principles or whatever else. They will assign a higher priority to increasing the economic and political power of the people they are trying to represent (or their designated representatives)...

Comments