Things to Read for Your Nighttime Procrastination on December 28, 2015
Liveblogging World War II: December 28, 1945: War Brides Act

(Late) Monday Smackdown: Randall Kennedy's Reasonable Discourses About Poicy Edition

Shakezulu: 3 Words that Rhyme: Sleight of Word from HLS: "I see Prof. Pull up Your Pants [Randall Kennedy] is at it again...

...and I hope people who enjoy a good goalpost shifting caught this one, buried (and rightfully so) in paragraph nine of 13....

Dissidents... complain... [about] white classmates who implicitly or even expressly question the intellectual capacity of black peers (‘You know, don’t you, that they are here only because of affirmative action’).... While some of these complaints have a ring of validity, several are dubious.... Opposition to racial affirmative action can stem from a wide range of sources other than prejudice. Racism and its kindred pathologies are already big foes; there is no sustained payoff in exaggerating their presence, thus making them more formidable than they actually are.

To review: A person... [claims] every black student was admitted due to affirmative action. This assertion Kennedy accepts without blinking, and for perfectly legitimate reasons that you must not question, quickly transubstantiates it into the airy realm of debate about policy. What sort of reasonable person would object to a reasoned debate about policy? None. And since objections to policy are always reasonable and could have any number of reasons, persons seeking to assign a specific reason to the objection are behaving unreasonably.

No. Stop. I know what you're thinking, and it cannot be done. Goalposts only travel away from their original position.

You cannot carry them back to the original statement and say 'This is not an objection to policy, that's a racist insult.'

Now please wait quietly until someone provides a list of objections to policy. And pull your pants up.

Comments